CBI chargesheets 17 persons in All India Post Graduate Medical Entrance-2002 paper leak case

New Delhi, 01.09.2005

The Central Bureau of Investigation has found that the question paper of All India Post Graduate Medical Entrance Examination-2002 (AIPGMEE) was leaked after pilferring it from the Centennial Inter College, Gopalganj, Lucknow which was one of the examination centres. It also found that many of the successful candidates in the said examination including top rank holders benefitted from the leaked question paper.

After completion of investigation, CBI laid a chargesheet against Dr.Dhirender Singh, Jainender Kumar Shahi, Sunit Singh @ Baboo, B.D. Mishra, K.C. Bhargava, Dr.K.K. Singh, Dr. Raj Kumar Chaudhary, Dr.Avinash Gahlot, Dr.Mayank Shukla, Dr.Ravinder Kumar Umrao, Dr.Sunil Kumar, Dr.Birendra Singh, Dr.(Mrs) Santosh Singh, Dr. Nar Singh, Dr. Raj Kumar, Dr.Shyam Singh and Dr.Ajit Singh, under sections 120-B, 457, 380, 411 IPC in the court of Special Judicial Magistrate, Lucknow, on Monday last. CBI investigation revealed that Shyam Singh's son Sunit Singh @ Babloo, Dr. Dhirender Singh, an MBBS student at GSVM Medical College, Kanpur and Sh.Jainender Kumar Shahi along with others hatched a conspiracy to leak the question paper in order to sell it to prospective candidates for hefty amount of sum. The chargesheet alleges that Dr.Dhirender Singh was the master mind who wanted to give benefit to his elder brother Dr. Birender Singh and his sister-in-law Dr.(Mrs.) Santosh Singh who were also candidates in the examination. Both Dr. Birender Singh and Dr.(Mrs.) Santosh Singh were unsuccessful in the previous PG Entrance Examinations and hence, were desperate to clear that year's examination.

Sometime in the month of December,2001, Sunit Singh procured the key to the office of the Principal, Centennial Inter College. A duplicate key was got prepared by Sunit Singh and Jainender Kumar Shahi from a locksmith. By using the duplicate key, the question paper was taken out and photocopied. The accused persons had contacted candidates of this examination and mediators including Bhardwaj Mishra, Krishna Chandra Bhargava, Dr.K.K. Singh and Dr.Raj Kumar Chaudhary prior to leaking of the question paper.

The examination was conducted on 6/1/2002. However, late in the evening of 4/1/2002, Dr.Dhirender Singh brought a Marshal Jeep from his friend Dr.Manoj Kumar Singh. Sunit Singh, Jainender Kumar Shahi and Dr.Dhirender Singh were already keeping watch on the arrival of the box containing the question paper at Centennial Inter College. They opened the Principal's Chamber by using the duplicate key. They had brought along with them a locksmith. However, they were unable to open the lock of the box containing the question booklets. Therefore, they carried the box to the rented room of one Vinay Pratap Singh who was a friend of Jainender Kumar Shahi. The lock was opened with the help of another locksmith and the question booklet was carefully extracted from the sealed envelopes from inside the box. Subsequently, the question paper was photocopied and it was leaked to several candidates in Lucknow as well as in Delhi and other places. CBI found that the pilferred question paper was leaked to several candidates including Dr.Avinash Gahlot, Dr.Mayank Shukla, Dr. Ravindra Kumar Umrao, Dr.Sunil Kumar, Dr.Birender Singh, Dr.(Mrs.) Santosh Singh, Dr. Nar Singh, Dr. Raj Kumar and Dr.Shyam Singh.

The case was registered by CBI in compliance with the orders of the Delhi High Court, dated 6.6.2002. AIPGMEE-2002 for admission to MD/MS/MDS courses against 25% All India Quota in the Medical Colleges of the country was scheduled to be conducted by All India Post Graduate Medical Sciences (AIIMS), New Delhi on 6/1/2002 at 61 centres in 15 cities of India. An anonymous letter dated 31/12/2001 was received in AIIMS on 1.1.2002 enclosing therewith an advertisement published in a leading newspaper dated 29.12.2001 in the name of Shiksha Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for "Confirm Admission" in MD/MS. The informer mentioned that he was asked to arrange Rs.10 lakh and was given assurance of the question paper of AIPGMEE-2002 would be given to him on the night before to the examination. On receipt of this information, the then Deputy Director (Admn) -cum CVO, AIIMS New Delhi, informed the Delhi Police.

The Delhi Police on 4.1.2002 carried out a raid at the premises of M/S Shiksha Consultants, the office of one Pawan Thakur and recovered several post dated cheques amounting to Rs.1.60 crores, photocopies of admit cards of some candidates of AIPGMEE-2002, carbon copies of the agreements made by Pawan Thakur with candidats/gurdians of the candidates, blank proformas on stamp papers, plain paper for executing agreements etc. The Delhi Police also arrested Pawan Thakur and three others namely, Shreekant, Mukesh and Nikesh on 4.1.2002.

The results of AIPGMEE-2002 was declared on 15.02.2002 and the results from the Lucknow centre were extremely good. Some candidates filed Writ Petitions in the High Court of Delhi seeking cancellation of the results alleging that there had been widespread leakage of question paper and that many of the mediocre students bagged top ranks in this examination because of leakage. In the meanwhile, after completing investigation, Delhi Police filed a chargesheet against Pawan Thakur, Shreekant, Mukesh and Nikesh for hatching conspiracy to induce several candidates to part with post-dated cheques as advance payments against the promise of providing solved question papers of this examination. However, the Delhi Police could not detect the leakage of question paper. This chargesheet is pending trial in the court of M.M. Delhi.