Is this the end of Shiv Sena?

Print this page
- by Parinda News Bureau, November 23, 2005

The downslide of Shiv Sena began with the departure of Chhagan Bhujbal. Bhujbal was disgusted with the factionalism in Sena being ruled by an autocratic Balasaheb Thackeray and when he parted ways, optimists in Sena thought he would go the way others went in the past - in oblivion and political wilderness.

Dr Hemchandra Gupte is one of those one remembers who, disgusted with the style of Thackeray, decided to leave the party. The violent Sainiks made his life difficult. One still remember how his hands shook during the critical period. There also was Bandu Shingre who had the audacity to form Prati-Shiv Sena; to end up in oblivion.

This didn't happen to Bhujbal. All Balasaheb's horses and all Balasaheb's men couldn't put the humpty dumpty together again. Bhujbal's bungalow was attacked by violent sainiks and Thackeray used his Thakeri language, as he proudly calls this volley of abuse against Bhujbal, tried to finish him in elections making it a personal prestige issue but failed. Bhujbal went on to become the Deputy Chief Minister of Maharashtra and in fact, scared Thackeray with arrest warrant!

With public memory being what it is this became an old story till the memories were revived when Narayan Rane dumped Sena. Rane's departure has been a bigger jolt for Balasaheb than that of Bhujbal. Shiv Sena candidate opposite him lost his deposit despite every senior Shiv Sena leader campaigning for him. Rane's margin was amazing. Shiv Sena has been wiped out in Malvan and Rane is a threat that may spell doom for this party.

The way Thackeray handled the election of Priya Dutt sent mixed signals even to his own sainiks. The sainiks were further demoralized when hardly anyone that mattered campaigned for Madhukar Sarpotdar. Losing this election was a shame specially when a series of happenings seemed against Priya Dutt. Abu Salem's presence threatened to open Dutt's Pandara's Box and the accusations against Sanjay Dutt were again on the front pages.

But Shiv Sena couldn't take advantage of this situation. No one is sure whether Raj Thackeray, who kept away from Malvan elections, really has a back problem or simply refused to campaign for the Sena. Many believe that Raj Thackeray, as the leader of Shiv Sena, can be a better choice over Balasaheb's first choice, his son Udhav. The issues between Udhav Thackeray and cousin Raj Thackeray have not been sorted out. Not yet, in any case.

Shiv Sena still is the ruling party in the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai, budget of which is more than some of the states in India. But this is the last year. A year later, corporation elections will be the final answer. If Shiv Sena lost in those elections, it will take the party a l-o-n-g time to make a comeback.